| Related sites for http://userwww.service.emory.edu/~cescoff/employ.html |
| All_Things_Spiritual Includes all major spiritual and religious categories, as well as related forums and polls. | | Alternative_Religions Information, annotated links and reviews on various lesser known religions. | | Blessings_Cornucopia Definitions of religions and beliefs, ancient civilizations, Goddesses and Gods, spiritual and ritual items, and a variety of other related topics. | | Directory_of_Religious_Centers Directory of non-Christian and non-Jewish religious centers in the United States, including Buddhist, Hindu, Jain, Zoroastrian, Bahai, Pagan, Islamic, Tao centers and temples. | | Dragon_Search Search engine for sites focusing on Buddhism and Eastern Religions. | | Erowid_Buddhism_Vault Information about religion and religious practices as a spiritual path. | | God_com Exploration of religion on the Web, featuring reporting, interviews, and sound. From Time magazine. | | Religious_Resources_on_the_Internet A searchable directory of Internet resources for all major religions, listing thousands of resources organized into hundreds of categories. | | Armed_Forces_and_HIV/AIDS Presented by The Body, a collection of articles and Web links on HIV/AIDS in the military, and the discharge of HIV positive soldiers. | | Healthcare_Workers_and_AIDS_prevention Needlestick injury and the risk of HIV transmission in health care setting. Includes statistical information in occupational settings and Post Exposure Prophylaxis (PEP). | | Healthcare_Workers_and_HIV/AIDS Resources related to protecting health care workers (including dental professionals) from occupational exposure to post-exposure prevention, presented by The Body. | | HIV_at_Work__Tools_-_Manager\'s_Kit_and_Labor_Leader\'s_Kit Enable managers and labor leaders to develop HIV/AIDS policies in their workplaces; train managers and labor leaders to conduct HIV/AIDS workshops; educate employees and workers about basic facts abou | | HIV_Exposure_Issues A comprehensive resource on occupational and other exposure issues to HIV/AIDS, from AEGIS. | | MIL_POZ A forum for anyone with questions or comments about HIV and the military, includes facts on military HIV infection figures and detection rates. | | _Workers_and_HIV/AIDS Topics from The Body related to HIV and AIDS among workers, including prostitution, , and government surveillance. | | About_com__Crime_and_Punishment Articles, news, and annotated link directory covering crime and organized crime around the world. | | Alternatives_com__Organized_Crime Collection of documents, essays and speeches relating to crime, categorized by region and type. | | The_American_Mafia__Kefauver_Committee_Reports Full text of the interim and final reports of the U.S. Senate Special Committee to Investigate Organized Crime in Interstate Commerce, 1950-1951. | | American_Organized_Crime Collection of articles on organized crime and the Mafia in the USA, focused on gangsters in New York and Chicago before and during the Prohibition. | | American_Organized_Crime__Two_Men_Can_Keep_a_Secret,_If_One_is_Dead Site provides information on ethnic organized crime - including Irish Mob, Italian Cosa Nostra, Russian Organizitskya, Albanian Mob - and street gangs. Mob boss succession, mug shots and articles on u | | AML_Canada Resources, references and links relating to anti-moneylaundering, proceeds of crime and asset forfeiture law and programs in Canada | | Asian_Organized_Crime_in_Australia A 1995 discussion paper by the Australian Parliamentary Joint Committee on the National Crime Authority. Paper deals with Chinese (Triads), Vietnamese and Japanese (Yakuza) ethnic criminal entities in | | Black_Market_News Updates on organized crime from news sources around the world. Deals with black markets, government corruption, and inadequate government intervention. | | Criminal_Justice_Resources__Organized_Crime Compilation of web resources on American and international organized crime with detailed descriptions. | | FBI__Investigative_Programs_-_Organized_Crime The Bureau defines its Organized Crime Program. Site includes discussions of transnational crime, regional/ethnic studies, applicable statutes (such as RICO) and case summaries. | | Gang_Land Jerry Capeci, longtime reporter and columnist with The New York Daily News, shares his perspective on organized crime. Site includes histories of the regional crime families, weekly columns, biographi | | GangRule Features a database of organized crime families and notable historic events, photographs, mugshots, newspaper clippings, and official documents | | Gangsterologists Online discussion group for true crime writers, researchers. Site features a forum and polls. Forum message text is available as an RSS News Feed. | | Gangsters_Incorporated Profiles of major crime families and gangsters. Includes a discussion forum. | | International_Association_for_the_Study_of_Organized_Crime Professional association founded in 1984 to promote understanding and research. Site contains member list, book reviews, news, links. | | IPSN__Bill_Roemer_on_Las_Vegas_Mobsters A former FBI agent's discussion of mob involvement in Sin City gambling. | | Mob-News News items and observations about the American Mafia and other elements of worldwide organized crime. | | Mr__Murder A collection of stories and photos relating to organized crime and law enforcement. Photos are provided of gangster gravesites and noteworthy crime scenes. | | NewCriminologist__Organized_Crime_News News and history articles from the criminology journal's online edition. Some content available only to paid members. | | Organized_Crime_Research Articles, abstracts, book reviews and links with a focus on criminal organizations in the U.S. and in Germany. | | Organized_Crime_Syndicates Listings of organized crime groups throughout the USA and worldwide. Biographical entries, mugshots, chatroom, forum for questions and comments. | | Reputed_Links_to_Organized_Crime An irreverant organized crime site, with links to other sites. | | Stop_Organized_Stalking Information on a form of gang intimidation. Site includes photos and videos. | | Suite_101_com__Organized_Crime_Issues Provides history and updates related to organized crime, with information about specific wiseguys and crime history events. | | Transnational_Crime_and_Corruption_Center Devoted to better understanding of crime scope and causes and to formulating policy to reduce the problem. |
|
This is an outline of 1996 developments in employment discrimination
law. This outline focuses primarily on Eleventh Circuit law, although it
includes case law from other Circuits as well. It is by no means comprehensive,
but it provides some insight into the development of this ever-changing
area of the law. I have cited mostly to the slip opinion cites, but by
the time you read this, citations to F.3d, S. Ct., or F. Supp. should be
available for most of these cases.
A. Age Discrimination in Employment Act ("ADEA")
1. ADEA Prima Facie Case.
In O'Connor v. Consolidated Coin Caterers, No. 95-354, slip op.
(April 4, 1996), the Supreme Court rejected as the fourth element of a
prima facie case under the ADEA that the plaintiff was replaced by a person
outside of his protected class, that is, by a person under the age of forty.
The Court found that "the fact that a replacement is substantially
younger than the plaintiff is a far more reliable indicator of age discrimination
than is the fact that the plaintiff was replaced by someone outside the
protected class." Id. Therefore, a plaintiff may present a
prima facie case of age discrimination under the ADEA by
showing that (1) he was over age forty, (2) he was qualified to do the
job, (3) he was subject to an adverse employment action, and (4) he was
replaced by a "substantially younger" person. Id.
B. Title VII
1. Comparators.
a. Employees lower in corporate hierarchy not similarly situated.
In determining whether employees are similarly situated, a jury can
consider the fact that the comparators were lower in the corporate hierarchy
than plaintiff. It would not be contrary to law for an employer to require
employees with more authority to conform to a higher standard of decency
than those with less authority. Hargett v. Nat. Westminster Bank, USA,
78 F.3d 836 (2d Cir. 1996), cert. denied, __ U.S. __, No. 95-2071, 1996
WL 375941 (Oct. 7, 1996).
2. ual Harassment.
a. Constructive knowledge of ual harassment.
An employer had constructive knowledge of ual harassment because
all of the supervisors with whom the victims had regular contact were harassers
and the employer failed to provide the victims with guidance as to how
they could contact upper-level managers to complain of harassment. Splunge
v. Shoney's, Inc., __ F.3d __, No. 95-6141, 1996 WL 544027 (11th Cir.
Oct. 10, 1996).
b. Abusive investigation of ual harassment is not harassment itself.
The abusive investigation of a false claim of ual harassment is not
itself a form of ual harassment actionable under Title VII. McDonnell
v. Cisneros, No. 95-1864, slip op. (7th Cir. May 20, 1996).
c. Code words and ual harassment.
Facially neutral "code words" can violate Title VII when circumstances
indicate that racial (or ual) implications were intended. This type
of comment can be evidence of a hostile work environment if derogatory
and insulting terms are pervasively used and directed at members of a protected
class. Aman v. Cort Furniture Rental Corp., No. 95-5142, slip op.
(3d Cir. June 5, 1996).
d. No hostile work environment claim for harassment of heteroual
male by heteroual male.
In McWilliams v. Fairfax County Bd. of Supervisors, No. 94-1607,
slip op. (4th Cir. Jan. 9, 1996), the Fourth Circuit held that harassment
that is ual in nature, but committed by heteroual males against a
heteroual male employee, is not harassment "because of ."
Therefore, the court held that the employee could not maintain a Title
VII hostile work environment ual harassment claim on such facts.
3. Direct Evidence
a. Discriminatory comment, unrelated to decision, not direct evidence.
A supervisor's admission that he told racial jokes and used the "N"
word was not direct evidence against a black job applicant when the remarks
were not made about the applicant himself and were unrelated to the hiring
decision. Allen v. City of Athens, __ F. Supp. __, No. CV95-H-1083,
1996 WL 501883 (N.D. Ala. Sept. 3, 1996).
b. Must be statement of decisionmaker to constitute direct evidence.
"For statements of discriminatory intent to constitute direct evidence
of discrimination, they must be made by a person involved in the challenged
action." Trotter v. Bd. of Trustees of Univ. Of Ala., No. 95-6465,
slip op. at 3201 (11th Cir. Aug. 20, 1996).
4. Constructive Discharge.
a. No constructive discharge if employee does not give employer time
to remedy problem before quitting.
"A constructive discharge will generally not be found if the employer
is not given sufficient time to remedy the situation." Kilgore
v. Thompson & Brock Management, No. 94-7018, slip op. (11th Cir.
Sept. 5, 1996).
5. Reasonable accommodation of religion.
School district's refusal to give school bus drivers all of the unpaid
leave they requested so that they could attend a religious observance was
not religious discrimination in violation of Title VII. Requiring the school
district to hire more drivers and pay drivers more to cover the absences
would have imposed an undue hardship on the school district, which had
suffered a budget deficit of over six million dollars the previous year.
Favero v. Huntsville Ind. Sch. Dist., __ F. Supp. __, No. CIV A
H-95-3547, 1996 WL 529309 (S.D. Tex. Aug. 9, 1996).
6. Arbitration agreement can stay Title VII action.
An arbitration clause in an employment agreement, which obligated the
parties to arbitrate all claims arising out of federal, state, and local
statutes, required a stay of an employment discrimination action. The Civil
Rights Act of 1991 revealed express congressional approval of the use of
arbitration to resolve Title VII disputes. Johnson v. Hubbard Broadcasting,
Inc., __ F. Supp. __, No. CIV 4-96-107, 1996 WL 511585 (D. Minn. Sept.
3, 1996).
7. Employee may release employer from Title VII liability
"When an employee knowingly and voluntarily releases an employer
from liability for Title VII and § 1981 claims with a full understanding
of the terms of the agreement, he is bound by that agreement. . . . However,
the waiver of such remedial rights must be closely scrutinized." Puentes
v. United Parcel Service, Inc., No. 95-4374, slip op. (11th Cir. June
20, 1996).
C. Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA")
1. Title I of ADA does not apply to former employees.
Title I of the ADA does not apply to former employees. Gonzales v.
Garner Food Servs. Inc., No. 95-8533, slip op. (11th Cir. Aug. 2, 1996).
2. Withdrawal of accommodation under ADA raises issue of pretext.
Withdrawal of a reasonable offer of accommodation after it has been
accepted gives rise to an inference of pretext and intentional discrimination
under the ADA. Valentine v. American Home Shield Corp., __ F. Supp.
__, No. C 95-3030-MWB, 1996 WL 506506 (N.D. Iowa Aug. 30, 1996).
3. Reassignment not required as reasonable accommodation under ADA
if it would violate collective bargaining agreement
Reasonable accommodation does not require reassignment of disabled employee
in derogation of collectively bargained seniority rights of other employees.
Eckles v. Consolidated Rail Corp., No. 95-2856, slip op. (7th Cir.
August 14, 1996).
4. The Eleventh Circuit has stated the elements for an ADA claim.
The ADA provides that no employer with 15 or more employees "shall
discriminate against a qualified individual with a disability because of
the disability of such individual . . ." in regard to their employment.
42 U.S.C. § 12112(a) (1994). To establish a prima facie case of discrimination
under the ADA, the plaintiff must prove: (1) that she has a disability,
(2) that she is a qualified individual, and (3) that she was subject to
unlawful discrimination because of her disability. Morisky v. Broward
County, No. 95-4808, slip op., (11th Cir. April 11, 1996).
5. Vague statements of disability are not enough to put employer on
notice for ADA claim.
"Vague or conclusory statements revealing an unspecified incapacity
are not sufficient to put an employer on notice of its obligations under
the ADA." Morisky v. Broward County, No. 95-4808, slip op.
(11th Cir. April 11, 1996).
6. Disabled employee must ask for specific accommodation.
Under the ADA, an otherwise qualified individual with a disability who
is able to perform the essential functions of the job with reasonable accommodation
is entitled to a reasonable accommodation. However, in general, "it
is the responsibility of the individual with a disability to inform the
employer that an accommodation is needed." 29 C.F.R. § 1630,
App. § 1630.9 (1994); see also, Whillock v. Delta Air Lines,
Inc., 1:93-CV-2712-FMH, slip op. at 15 (N.D. Ga. Aug. 15, 1995) ("Under
the ADA, Plaintiff must offer Defendant a suggestion of a reasonable accommodation
which would allow her to perform the essential functions of her job.").
7. Under the ADA, an employer may require medical certification that
an employee or applicant is physically able to do the work.
The ADA allows inquiry into an applicant's ability to perform job-related
functions. It also allows employer to require a former employee with a
recent known disability, who is applying for re-employment, to furnish
a medical certification as to the ability to work, with or without reasonable
accomodation, provided that such certification is relevant to an assessment
of the individual's ability to perform essential job functions. Grenier
v. Cynamid Plastics Inc., No. 95-1313, slip op. (1st Cir. Nov. 27,
1995).
8. Employee must provide information needed to accommodate disability.
An employee who failed to sign a release to enable her employer to consult
her doctor and otherwise failed to provide information needed to accommodate
her disability cannot recover under the ADA. Beck v. Univ. of Wisc.
Bd. of Regents, No. 95-2479, slip op. (7th Cir. Jan. 26, 1996).
D. Age Discrimination in Employment Act ("ADEA")
1. Disparate impact established under the ADEA.
A former employee established a prima facie case of disparate impact
age discrimination under the ADEA based on her employer's salary restructuring.
Data presented by the employee showed that less than five percent of employees
under age forty received wage reductions of three dollars pre hour or more,
while seventy-five percent of those over age forty received comparable
reductions. The employer failed to articulate any reason other than age
to explain the policy's disparate impact. Camacho v. Sears Roebuck de
Puerto Rico, __ F. Supp. __, No. CIV 94-2055(PG), 1996 WL 535394 (D.P.R.
Sept. 17, 1996).
E. State law claims.
1. Intentional infliction of emotional distress.
a. Allegations of harassment for reporting dangerous work conditions
is enough to survive summary judgment on claim of intentional infliction
of emotional distress.
The Eleventh Circuit recently affirmed the district court's denial of
a Rule 12(b)(6) Motion to Dismiss plaintiff's claim of intentional infliction
of emotional distress when he alleged that he reported dangerous work conditions
and was thereafter harassed and ultimately terminated. Harris v. Procter
& Gamble Cellulose Co., No. 95-8602, Slip op. (11th Cir. Jan. 22,
1996).
2. Punitive Damages Under State Law May Be Excessive
The Supreme Court has held that a punitive damages award may be so "grossly
excessive" as to violate the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth
Amendment. BWM of North America, Inc. v. Gore, No. 94-896, slip
op. (May 20, 1996) (voiding an Alabama state court's award of punitive
damages against BMW for failing to disclose that it repainted a new $40,000
car, thereby reducing its value by $4,000).
F. Summary judgment standard.
1. Ultimate issue on summary judgment is whether jury could infer discrimination.
"At the summary judgment stage, our inquiry is whether an ordinary
person could reasonably infer discrimination if the facts presented remained
unrebutted." Jameson v. Arrow Co., No. 94-8772, slip op. (11th
Cir. Feb. 28, 1996).
2. Employee must show all of defendant's proffered reasons to be pretextual
to survive summary judgment.
An employee who raised fact issues as to four of the employer's six
proffered reasons for his termination failed to survive summary judgment
in an ADEA action, when the four disputed reasons were neither so intertwined
nor so fishy so as to call into doubt the two credible reasons. Wolf
v. Buss America, Inc., 77 F.3d 914 (7th Cir. 1996), cert. denied, __
U.S. __, No. 96-92, 1996 WL 411488 (Oct. 7, 1996).
3. Qualified immunity and mixed motive at summary judgment.
An official is entitled to qualified immunity at the summary judgment
stage if both a lawful and unlawful motive are present and a jury could
find that the official would have made the same decision absent the unlawful
motivation. Foy v. Holston, No. 95-6227, slip op. at 3565 (11th
Cir. Sept. 17, 1996) ("Where the facts assumed for summary judgment
purposes in a case involving qualified immunity show mixed motives (lawful
and unlawful motivations) and pre-existing law does not dictate that the
merits of the case must be decided in plaintiff's favor, the defendant
is entitled to immunity.").
|
|
